A federal judge on Monday questioned whether the Trump administration ignored his orders to turn around planes carrying deportees to El Salvador, a possible violation of the decision he’d issued minutes before.
District Judge James E. Boasberg was incredulous over the administration’s contentions that his spoken directions did not count, that only his written order needed to be followed, that it couldn’t apply to flights that had left the U.S. and that the administration could not answer his questions about the deportations because of national security issues.
“That’s one heck of a stretch, I think,” Boasberg replied, noting that the administration knew as the planes were departing that he was about to decide whether to briefly halt deportations being made under a rarely used 18th century law invoked by President Trump about an hour earlier.
“I’m just asking how you think my equitable powers do not attach to a plane that has departed the U.S., even if it’s in international airspace,” Boasberg said at another point.
Deputy Associate Atty. Gen. Abhishek Kambli contended that only Boasberg’s short written order, issued about 45 minutes after he made the spoken demand, counted. It did not contain any demands to reverse planes, and Kambli added that it was too late to redirect two planes that had left the U.S. by that time.
“These are sensitive, operational tasks of national security,” Kambli said.
The hearing over what Boasberg called the “possible defiance” of his court order marked the latest step in a high-stakes legal fight that began when Trump invoked the 1798 wartime law to remove immigrants over the weekend. It was also an escalation in the battle over whether the Trump administration is flouting court orders that have blocked some of his aggressive moves in the opening weeks of his second term.
“There’s been a lot of talk about constitutional crisis, people throw that word around. I think we’re getting very close to it,” warned Lee Gelernt of the American Civil Liberties Union, the lead attorney for the plaintiffs, during the Monday hearing. After the hearing, Gelernt said the ACLU would ask Boasberg to order all improperly deported people returned to the United States.
Boasberg said he’d record the proceedings and additional demands in writing. “I will memorialize this in a written order since apparently my oral orders don’t seem to carry much weight,” Boasberg said.
On Saturday night, Boasberg ordered the administration not to deport anyone in its custody through the Alien Enemies Act, which has been used only three times before in U.S. history, all during congressionally declared wars. Trump issued a proclamation that the law was newly in effect because of what he claimed was an invasion by the Venezuelan gang Tren de Aragua.
Trump’s invocation of the act could allow him to deport any noncitizen he says is associated with the gang, without offering proof or even publicly identifying them. The plaintiffs filed their suit on behalf of several Venezuelans in U.S. custody who feared they’d be falsely accused of being Tren de Aragua members and improperly removed from the country.
Told there were planes in the air headed to El Salvador, which has agreed to house deported migrants in a notorious prison, Boasberg said Saturday evening that he and the government needed to move fast. “You shall inform your clients of this immediately, and that any plane containing these folks that is going to take off or is in the air needs to be returned to the United States,” Boasberg told the government’s lawyer.
According to the filing, two planes that had taken off from Texas’ detention facility when the hearing started more than an hour earlier were in the air at that point, and they apparently continued to El Salvador. A third plane apparently took off after the hearing and Boasberg’s written order was formally published at 7:26 p.m. Eastern time. Kambli said that plane held no one deported under the Alien Enemies Act.
El Salvador’s president, Nayib Bukele, on Sunday morning tweeted, “Oopsie … too late,” above an article referencing Boasberg’s order and announced that more than 200 deportees had arrived in his country. The White House communications director, Steven Cheung, reposted Bukele’s post with an admiring GIF.
Later Sunday, a widely circulated article in Axios said the administration decided to “defy” the order and quoted anonymous officials who said they concluded it didn’t extend to planes outside U.S. airspace. That drew a quick denial from White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt, who said in a statement “the administration did not ‘refuse to comply’ with a court order.”
The administration argues that a federal judge does not have the authority to tell the president whether he can determine the country is being invaded under the act, or how to defend it.
After Boasberg scheduled a hearing Monday and said the government should be prepared to answer questions over its conduct, the Justice Department objected, saying it could not answer in a public forum because it involved “sensitive questions of national security, foreign relations, and coordination with foreign nations.” Boasberg denied the government’s request to cancel the hearing, which led the Trump administration to ask that the judge be taken off the case.
Kambli stressed that the government believes it is complying with Boasberg’s order. It has said in writing it will not use Trump’s invocation of the Alien Enemies Act to deport anyone if Boasberg’s order is not overturned on appeal, a pledge Kambli made again orally in court Monday. “None of this is necessary because we did comply with the court’s written order,” Kambli said.
As the courtroom drama built, so did international fallout over the deportations to El Salvador. Venezuela’s government on Monday characterized the transfer of migrants to El Salvador as “kidnappings” that it plans to challenge as “crimes against humanity” before the United Nations and other international organizations. It also accused the Central American nation of profiting off the plights of Venezuelan migrants.
“They are not detaining them, they are kidnapping them and expelling them,” Jorge Rodriguez, President Nicolas Maduro’s chief negotiator with the U.S., told reporters Monday.
Trump’s proclamation alleges Tren de Aragua is acting as a “hybrid criminal state” in partnership with Venezuela.
Whitehurst and Cano write for the Associated Press and reported from Washington and Caracas, Venezuela, respectively. Joshua Goodman in Miami, Michael Kunzelman in Washington and Nicholas Riccardi in Denver contributed to this report.
